In this episode, Dr. Johnson gets into the psychological reasons why sports betting can be so enticing, exploring the mental traps and risk factors involved. It also provides practical strategies for individuals struggling with sports betting to regain control and find healthier coping mechanisms.
In this episode, Dr. Johnson gets into the psychological reasons why sports betting can be so enticing, exploring the mental traps and risk factors involved. It also provides practical strategies for individuals struggling with sports betting to regain control and find healthier coping mechanisms.
Transcript: https://savvy-psychologist.simplecast.com/episodes/why-your-brain-loves-sports-betting-and-how-to-stop/transcript
Have a mental health question? Email us at psychologist@quickanddirtytips.com or leave a voicemail at 929-256-2191.
Find Savvy Psychologist on Facebook and Twitter, or subscribe to the newsletter for more psychology tips.
Savvy Psychologist is a part of Quick and Dirty Tips.
Links:
https://quickanddirtytips.com/savvy-psychologist
https://www.facebook.com/savvypsychologist
https://twitter.com/qdtsavvypsych
https://www.kindmindpsych.com/
Let’s keep it real, shall we? Sports betting used to be something your uncle did at barbershop pools or during March Madness. Now? It’s an app in your pocket, one push notification away, with odds and parlays so seductive they make a Nashville hot chicken sandwich look bland.
If you’ve ever found yourself yelling at your phone during a game or convincing yourself that your fantasy football “research” is practically a PhD, you’re not the only one. If you’re the partner or parent of someone who perhaps struggles with sports betting and doesn't know what it is or what to do. It’s not you, it’s the app because these betting platforms, they’re engineered to exploit your psychology. As your favorite internet psychologist, I’m here to walk you through why sports betting is so psychologically addictive, who’s most at risk, what signs to look out for, and what you can actually do about it.
Welcome back to Savvy Psychologist, I'm your host, Dr. Monica Johnson. Every week on this show, I'll help you face life's challenges with evidence-based approaches, a sympathetic ear, and zero judgment.
Let’s start by discussing who’s most at risk for problem sports betting. To be clear: not everyone who bets has a problem. But there are certain risk factors that increase the likelihood of sports betting becoming harmful:
Young Age, Male Gender: Especially those aged 18–35.
Impulsivity & ADHD Traits: Folks with difficulty delaying gratification or regulating emotions may find betting irresistible.
Depression & Anxiety: Gambling can serve as a form of escape—but it often deepens the emotional lows.
High App Use: In-play bets and 24/7 access through mobile apps make impulsive decisions far too easy.
One study found that 75% of people with gambling problems had at least one co-occurring mental health condition. This is a public health issue—not just a “self-control” issue.
Let’s respond to the question everyone thinks they know the answer to:
“Why do people bet?” You might assume it’s all about getting rich quick. But in reality, psychological research paints a much more layered picture.
1. Excitement and Escapism
Some folks bet because it makes the game more exciting. You’re not just watching—it matters. That shot in the final seconds? Suddenly it’s not just drama; it’s your rent money. Research says that gambling activates the brain’s reward system especially when it’s uncertain. That unpredictability is like catnip for the brain.
2. The Illusion of Control
We think we’ve got this. “I know this team.” “I’ve studied the stats.” “I have a system.” It’s all part of the illusion of control, a cognitive bias where we overestimate our ability to influence random outcomes. It’s why people think choosing their own lottery numbers increases their odds. Spoiler, it doesn’t.
3. Social Influence
Sports betting is often social. You’re in a group chat. Your boys are all placing bets. Everyone’s talking odds like it’s stock trading. There’s status and bonding in it, especially among men. Research has found that peer norms play a huge role in shaping how young men perceive sports betting. If everyone’s doing it, it doesn’t feel risky. It feels normal.
4. Financial Fantasy
Even when people say “it’s just for fun,” there’s often an underlying hope: “What if I do hit big?” That hope is powerful, especially in times of economic stress, job insecurity, or debt. Most people who are engaging in sports betting or playing the numbers on a regular basis have this fantasy.
Now that we’ve gone over the “why,” let’s talk about your brain for a minute. Not because it’s broken—because it’s predictable. There are some classic mental traps that pull people deeper into sports betting. They are:
1. The Gambler’s Fallacy
This can show like, “If my team’s lost 5 games in a row, they’re due for a win.”
Nope. Each event is independent. Your team is not a slot machine. But the brain craves patterns—even when they don’t exist.
2. Near-Miss Effect
Let’s say you almost hit a 5-leg parlay—just missed by one point. Instead of discouraging you, that almost-win fires up your brain like it was a win. That’s the near-miss effect, and it’s a big reason people keep playing.
3. Confirmation Bias
Like if you ignore the ESPN article saying your team is trash and cling to the tweet that says they’re “underrated.” Your brain loves to prove itself right—even when it’s wrong.
4. Optimism Bias
You believe you’re luckier or smarter than other bettors. Maybe you had a hot streak last month. So now you feel invincible. To be clear: you’re not. One study found that people with higher confidence in their skill often bet more and win less.
Let’s get to some strategies that can help you out. The first is understanding the impact on you. You know what’s not in the commercials with smiling sports bettors and fist bumps? The panic. The debt. The lies to partners. The sinking dread of checking your bank balance after a bad night.
There are psychological consequences to sports betting. The most common include:
Loss-Chasing: Trying to win back what you lost, often making things worse.
Depression & Anxiety: The cycle of hope, loss, shame, and secrecy takes a toll.
Sleep Problems: Nighttime is prime betting time—and prime overthinking time.
Relationship Conflict: Hiding money, mood swings, irritability? It adds up.
There are some studies that emphasized that problem gambling is linked with significantly increased suicidal ideation. We have to take this seriously.
Here’s the part that makes my psychologist blood boil: these apps and all apps really are designed to keep you engaged with:
Push Notifications: Timed to when you’re bored or vulnerable.
Bonuses and “Risk-Free” Bets: They sound generous, but they’re designed to hook you into bigger bets later.
Celebrities and Humor: Makes it seem harmless, even cool. Like it’s a fun little hobby.
It’s not your lack of willpower or resolve keeping you in the betting loop.
If you’re struggling with gambler’s brain. CBT helps identify the thoughts and beliefs that keep you stuck (“I can win it back,” “I’m due”) and replaces them with more realistic thinking. Being aware of your thought patterns and how they influence your habit is key in talking yourself back from that next bet.
Secondarily, put limits on your technology usage. Many apps allow you to limit time or money spent, block access temporarily, and/or make note of and monitor your patterns across time. Even if you or the person you know isn’t ready to stop engaging in this habit, having more information about your patterns is helpful. If you struggle to set these limits, that’s useful information as well because, honestly, if you didn’t have any problem with it you wouldn’t have as much resistance to these boundaries. In the same vein Check In With Your Triggers. Are you betting when you’re bored? Lonely? Stressed? Understanding your emotional triggers is key to changing your habits.
I would also encourage you to talk about it. Gambling thrives in silence. Whether it’s a therapist, friend, or support group, letting someone in is the first step to regaining control. Finally, you may need to set financial boundaries with yourself. Create a separate account for bills and essentials. Have a trusted friend or family member help you stay accountable.
If you’re struggling with sports betting, it doesn’t mean you’re weak, lazy, or stupid.It means you’ve been caught in a system designed to keep you hooked. And now? You’re choosing to understand it and reclaim your power. That’s brave.You deserve more than the highs and lows of a betting app. You deserve peace, stability, and joy that isn’t tied to a scoreboard. And if no one else told you today? You are not alone. You are not beyond help. And you are worth every ounce of support it takes to get ahead of this issue.
Do you have any burning mental health questions? Let me know! You can contact me via Instagram @kindmindpsych or via my email at psychologist@quickanddirtytips.com.
The Savvy Psychologist is a Quick and Dirty Tips podcast. It's audio engineered by Steve Riekeberg (RICKy-berg). Holly Hutchings is our Director of Podcasts. Our Podcast and Advertising Operations Specialist is Morgan Christiansen. And Nathaniel Hoopes is our Marketing contractor. Follow Savvy Psychologist on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts. That's all for this episode of Savvy Psychologist. Thanks for listening! I'll see you next week.